Flashback: The Old Politics of MMA
May 25, 2007 19:10:52 GMT -5
Post by LWPD on May 25, 2007 19:10:52 GMT -5
This week there has been mainstream coverage of the UFC in both Sports Illustrated and the NY Times. Here's a reminder of how things were back in the days before money took MMA mainstream. Never forget!
NY Times Dec 10, 1995 letter from John McCain
To the Sports Editor:
I am writing in response to Ira Berkow's column ("Better Than a Stick in the Eye," The Times, Nov. 14) on the extreme fighting event initially scheduled to occur in New York on Nov. 18.
I have not had the displeasure of viewing extreme fighting, but I have seen segments of its reprehensible predecessor, the "Ultimate Fighting Championship." These repugnant events should be banned because they pose unacceptable risks of severe injury to the participants, and for their glorification of cruelty.
Contrary to Berkow's comments, these events definitely have a harmful impact on "innocent bystanders" when young children are welcomed to cheer on the bloodshed and violence. Sanctioning such competitions merely because some people willingly participate in them is an abrogation of even the lowest standards of public decency.
Berkow is correct in saying education and health care are more urgent priorities for our society. However, our society is unnecessarily degraded when public officials turn a blind eye to dangerous blood sports, and others defend them as legitimate entertainment.
JOHN McCAIN Washington
The writer is a Republican senator from Arizona.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NY Times January 16, 1997
Giuliani to Try to Prevent 'Extreme Fighting' Match
By DAN BARRY Published: January 16, 1997
Just three months after New York became the first state in the nation to sanction an attraction known as extreme fighting, Mayor Rudolph W. Giuliani and other New York City leaders are banding together to try to prevent the no-holds-barred matches from taking place within the city.
Mr. Giuliani and the City Council Speaker, Peter F. Vallone, said they had agreed in a telephone discussion yesterday to explore ways to block a match scheduled to be staged in Manhattan on March 28. But they also acknowledged that the city may be powerless to counter a law, which Gov. George E. Pataki signed reluctantly in October, that places so-called extreme or ultimate fighting under the regulatory auspices of the State Athletic Commission.
''I think extreme fighting is disgusting, it's horrible,'' Mr. Giuliani said. ''I happen to be a boxing fan, have been all my life. And I know there are issues regarding boxing, and they are serious ones. But this is way beyond boxing. This is people brutalizing each other.''
Meanwhile, in Albany, the opposite argument was being presented by Joseph L. Bruno, the Senate majority leader. Mr. Bruno, a Republican, said that he had been instrumental in drafting and overseeing a bill to regulate the competitions. He said he had studied statistics indicating that extreme fighting was less dangerous than boxing, but he did not reveal the source of those statistics.
''We ought to regulate it in the same way that we regulate boxing,'' Mr. Bruno said. ''If someone can prove me wrong, then we will revisit the issue.''
The differing views reflect the debate over extreme fighting, as well as the puzzlement over how it became regulated in New York when other states, including Illinois and Missouri, have banned it as too violent. In a typical match, two fighters use tactics derived from various disciplines -- boxing, martial arts and even street brawling -- against each other. Although bloodshed is common, promoters say most matches end when the loser surrenders by tapping three times on the mat.
In late 1995, a company called Battlecade Inc. announced plans to hold an extreme fighting match at the Park Slope Armory in Brooklyn. But its promoter, Donald Zuckerman, met with immediate resistance from city officials, including Mayor Giuliani and State Senator Roy M. Goodman of Manhattan. Then Governor Pataki stepped in by revoking the permit for the state-owned armory, forcing Mr. Zuckerman to stage the pay-per-view event in Wilmington, N.C.
Senator Goodman and Governor Pataki both proposed legislation to ban the sport. At the same time, SEG Sports Corporation, which produces extreme fighting tournaments, hired a prominent Albany lobbyist, James D. Featherstonhaugh, to argue its case before legislators and state officials. According to the State Commission on Lobbying, Mr. Featherstonhaugh ranked third on its 1996 list of lobbyists who had earned the most money through August.
In a December 1995 letter made available by the State Commission on Lobbying, Mr. Featherstonhaugh laid out his proposed approach to his client, Robert Meyrowitz, the president of SEG Sports. Mr. Featherstonhaugh said his mission was to ''derail'' a plan to have ultimate fighting banned by meeting with legislators and by ''submitting proactive legislation'' that would lead to state regulation.
Mr. Featherstonhaugh said yesterday that his approach represented ''a case study for how to lobby on a piece of legislation.'' He said he first had to overcome the prejudices that many legislators had about the sport. He then encouraged prominent legislators to watch videotapes of entire matches.
''We succeeded in getting enough people to watch it,'' Mr. Featherstonhaugh said. ''Ultimately, we were able to get by what was really a great deal of misinformation.''
In exchange for his work, state records show, Mr. Featherstonhaugh received $48,000 plus expenses.
Mr. Bruno denied that lobbying had played a role in his decision to support extreme fighting. ''I've had a 10-minute conversation totally on it,'' he said.
He said his research discovered that while boxers have been killed in the ring, no one has died in ultimate fighting. ''You might say it is more humane,'' he said, ''even though the TV ads show blood, guts, gore all over the place. That's promotions.''
The new law opened New York to promoters of the sport. Next month, SEG Sports is staging an ultimate fighting match at the Niagara Falls Civic Center. Then Mr. Zuckerman, of Battlecade, is to return to New York City, with his plan to hold a tournament in Manhattan in March.
Mr. Zuckerman declined to disclose the location, saying that a contract had not been signed. ''Until the contract is executed, I'm not going to make an announcement,'' he said. ''I don't want politicians pressuring the venue. And I believe they will.''
His is an astute observation, said Mr. Vallone, the City Council Speaker. ''As soon as they disclose the location, you can be sure we will use all our resources to be present.''
NY Times Dec 10, 1995 letter from John McCain
To the Sports Editor:
I am writing in response to Ira Berkow's column ("Better Than a Stick in the Eye," The Times, Nov. 14) on the extreme fighting event initially scheduled to occur in New York on Nov. 18.
I have not had the displeasure of viewing extreme fighting, but I have seen segments of its reprehensible predecessor, the "Ultimate Fighting Championship." These repugnant events should be banned because they pose unacceptable risks of severe injury to the participants, and for their glorification of cruelty.
Contrary to Berkow's comments, these events definitely have a harmful impact on "innocent bystanders" when young children are welcomed to cheer on the bloodshed and violence. Sanctioning such competitions merely because some people willingly participate in them is an abrogation of even the lowest standards of public decency.
Berkow is correct in saying education and health care are more urgent priorities for our society. However, our society is unnecessarily degraded when public officials turn a blind eye to dangerous blood sports, and others defend them as legitimate entertainment.
JOHN McCAIN Washington
The writer is a Republican senator from Arizona.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NY Times January 16, 1997
Giuliani to Try to Prevent 'Extreme Fighting' Match
By DAN BARRY Published: January 16, 1997
Just three months after New York became the first state in the nation to sanction an attraction known as extreme fighting, Mayor Rudolph W. Giuliani and other New York City leaders are banding together to try to prevent the no-holds-barred matches from taking place within the city.
Mr. Giuliani and the City Council Speaker, Peter F. Vallone, said they had agreed in a telephone discussion yesterday to explore ways to block a match scheduled to be staged in Manhattan on March 28. But they also acknowledged that the city may be powerless to counter a law, which Gov. George E. Pataki signed reluctantly in October, that places so-called extreme or ultimate fighting under the regulatory auspices of the State Athletic Commission.
''I think extreme fighting is disgusting, it's horrible,'' Mr. Giuliani said. ''I happen to be a boxing fan, have been all my life. And I know there are issues regarding boxing, and they are serious ones. But this is way beyond boxing. This is people brutalizing each other.''
Meanwhile, in Albany, the opposite argument was being presented by Joseph L. Bruno, the Senate majority leader. Mr. Bruno, a Republican, said that he had been instrumental in drafting and overseeing a bill to regulate the competitions. He said he had studied statistics indicating that extreme fighting was less dangerous than boxing, but he did not reveal the source of those statistics.
''We ought to regulate it in the same way that we regulate boxing,'' Mr. Bruno said. ''If someone can prove me wrong, then we will revisit the issue.''
The differing views reflect the debate over extreme fighting, as well as the puzzlement over how it became regulated in New York when other states, including Illinois and Missouri, have banned it as too violent. In a typical match, two fighters use tactics derived from various disciplines -- boxing, martial arts and even street brawling -- against each other. Although bloodshed is common, promoters say most matches end when the loser surrenders by tapping three times on the mat.
In late 1995, a company called Battlecade Inc. announced plans to hold an extreme fighting match at the Park Slope Armory in Brooklyn. But its promoter, Donald Zuckerman, met with immediate resistance from city officials, including Mayor Giuliani and State Senator Roy M. Goodman of Manhattan. Then Governor Pataki stepped in by revoking the permit for the state-owned armory, forcing Mr. Zuckerman to stage the pay-per-view event in Wilmington, N.C.
Senator Goodman and Governor Pataki both proposed legislation to ban the sport. At the same time, SEG Sports Corporation, which produces extreme fighting tournaments, hired a prominent Albany lobbyist, James D. Featherstonhaugh, to argue its case before legislators and state officials. According to the State Commission on Lobbying, Mr. Featherstonhaugh ranked third on its 1996 list of lobbyists who had earned the most money through August.
In a December 1995 letter made available by the State Commission on Lobbying, Mr. Featherstonhaugh laid out his proposed approach to his client, Robert Meyrowitz, the president of SEG Sports. Mr. Featherstonhaugh said his mission was to ''derail'' a plan to have ultimate fighting banned by meeting with legislators and by ''submitting proactive legislation'' that would lead to state regulation.
Mr. Featherstonhaugh said yesterday that his approach represented ''a case study for how to lobby on a piece of legislation.'' He said he first had to overcome the prejudices that many legislators had about the sport. He then encouraged prominent legislators to watch videotapes of entire matches.
''We succeeded in getting enough people to watch it,'' Mr. Featherstonhaugh said. ''Ultimately, we were able to get by what was really a great deal of misinformation.''
In exchange for his work, state records show, Mr. Featherstonhaugh received $48,000 plus expenses.
Mr. Bruno denied that lobbying had played a role in his decision to support extreme fighting. ''I've had a 10-minute conversation totally on it,'' he said.
He said his research discovered that while boxers have been killed in the ring, no one has died in ultimate fighting. ''You might say it is more humane,'' he said, ''even though the TV ads show blood, guts, gore all over the place. That's promotions.''
The new law opened New York to promoters of the sport. Next month, SEG Sports is staging an ultimate fighting match at the Niagara Falls Civic Center. Then Mr. Zuckerman, of Battlecade, is to return to New York City, with his plan to hold a tournament in Manhattan in March.
Mr. Zuckerman declined to disclose the location, saying that a contract had not been signed. ''Until the contract is executed, I'm not going to make an announcement,'' he said. ''I don't want politicians pressuring the venue. And I believe they will.''
His is an astute observation, said Mr. Vallone, the City Council Speaker. ''As soon as they disclose the location, you can be sure we will use all our resources to be present.''